Well, top 15 is a little arbitrary. Against KenPom top 25 teams in out-of-conference games since 2015-16, UVA is 2-4.
The wins were both, as you note, in 2019 over Wiscy (#16) and MD (#24), in consecutive games, no less. Other than that, we’ve lost to WV (#7, 2017), WV again (#12, 2018), Purdue (#24, 2020), and of course Gonzaga (#1, 2021).
Interestingly, the only one of those games that happened at JPJ was the first loss to WV in 2017. Wiscy and Gonzaga were at neutral sites and the other 3 were all on the road. This makes me feel like good teams are doing their best to dodge UVA.
Here’s kind of an amazing stat to follow up on that. Excluding ACC games and ACC/Big10 challenge games which aren’t set by the schools, exactly 3 KenPom top 25 teams have intentionally chosen to play at JPJ during the entirety of CTB’s UVA career. That’s it. 3.
Those 3 are, in reverse chronological order: WV in 2017, Nova in 2016 and… VCU (#25) in 2014. So, initially it feels like maybe the good teams really are dodging UVA.
However, looking at on the road or at neutral sites during CTB’s tenure, UVA has played Washington (neutral, #16, 2011), Tennessee (away, #10, 2014), WV (neutral, #8, 2016), Nova, (away, #2, 2017), WV (away, #12, 2018), Wiscy (neutral, #16, 2019), and Gonzaga (neutral, #1, 2021). So that’s 3 away games and 4 neutral games. Those were some good teams, but we definitely aren’t stuck always playing good OOC teams on the road. Maybe we’re doing the dodging after all? I dunno.
