I get what he’s trying to do (guarantee more Quad 1 games for the top teams) but one big issue is determining that the season before is rickety, especially if teams are more likely to make drastic moves up or down in the portal era (assumption on my point). From a pure schedule optimization perspective, it would be better to do the schedule grouping based off of partial current season results, but that is logistically difficult. C-USA did it 1-2 years I believe, where the top-6 or so played their last 5 games against each other.
The promotion/relegation based off of previous season is a horrendous sell to fans though, especially when it hasn’t been the status quo.
Same. Also, those mid-major conferences have to do wacky things because they have a hard time building strong non-conference schedules and typically only have 1-2 teams who could get an at-large if things go well. The ACC has the option of just Being Good At Basketball if it wants more bids.
So my personal opinion based on my love of promotion/relegation leagues…
You can’t do this with a college-level sport.
Here is why:
Rosters are too volatile due to graduations/eligibility/transfers… professional leagues have players on contract and can stabilize the rosters with long term deals of superstars, trade/loan/buy players mid-season to get better, use their academies for homegrown talent.
It HAS to be a balanced schedule… any gimmick where you have rivalry games across tiers that counted towards the standings would invalidate the whole process. Home/Home within your tier or it will invite controversy. Not guaranteeing the annual rivalry games would invite controversy.
Media partners would not want a bad UNC or Duke aberration team get demoted. As @haney mentioned above, it wouldn’t fly until a new media rights deal could be reached and if I’m ESPN, CBS, NBC… I don’t want to lose out on Duke/UNC game or 2 in a season I own the rights just because the league has relegation/promotion. Why would they lose out? Because see reason #2.
The folks in Europe that don’t like promotion/relegation say it favors larger population centers with higher revenue teams. There was a season a few years ago where there were no Premier League teams in any part of the West Midlands (neither Birmingham team, Reading & nothing in Cornwall - I know southwest so sue me)… that same year there were 7-teams in London. With NIL… this could be the ACC reality with the more financed teams never getting demoted.
I love promotion/relegation… so it has to be done correctly… this would just be dumb promotion/relegation if the ACC does this.
Brilliant move on his part. (A) wouldn’t be the first power forward to make a move to tight end, a couple of guys even making the NFL, following the Jimmy Graham path (four years playing hoops at Miami before one season of football and then the NFL), and (B) if he DOES keep pursuing the 5th year for hoops (probably a better immediate payday), it keeps him in school working out.
I mean, if some random number called me (well first of all, I don’t answer my phone if I’m not expecting a call) and said he was Ryan Odom asking me to renew my season tickets, I don’t think I’d believe it either. But I guess if I took a minute to think about it, I don’t have friends/enemies who would try to prank me like that and unless they’re asking me for a credit card or something, there’s no payoff if it’s a scam.
Sam seems very high on Coward. Norlander mentioned on the cbs podcast the other day that Vecenie had specifically called him out when Norlander was putting together his top 100 players before last year. (Sam and Norlander used to work at CBS together)
Speaking of…here’s some potential rage bait for your Friday morning. Also, Cassell North is funny considering they’ve won in Cville 2x in the last 15 years
Realized I just sparked a potential debate and now fully expect Dave to argue VT’s side
Tech is gonna kick our butt!!! …. In wrestling…
I’ll believe anything basketball related there when I see it.
Edit - in Reading through some of that to be reminded that we had the same record as them in conference play last year was shocking… I had kinda edited that from my brain.
Time for a return to normalcy for the Hoos!!