On Odom, and most of you know my position there — he jumps too fast for anyone to conclude whether he can sustain a program or recruit, his UMBC program steadily declined after his “one shining moment,” VCU and Utah State are winners despite who’s coaching, he’s already pushing 51 — but the thing that gives me the most pause is that the first P5 job an ex-VCU or Utah State coach takes is largely not successful in the way we’d view “success.”
Really, only Larry Eustachy and Will Wade were — and both lost their jobs at Iowa State and LSU, respectively, for extracurricular activities, so to speak.
We believe Pete Gillen to have been unsuccessful — over seven years he won 55.9% of his games, and took a team to the NCAAs only once.
Capel won 58.2% of his games, and two NCAAs over five years at Oklahoma. Bought out.
Grant won 57.9% of his games, and one NCAA in six years at Alabama. Bought out.
Smart won 55.9% of his games at Texas, earning three bids in six years. He jumped before he was bought out.
Rhoades is 31-32 in his two years at Penn State, and, barring a miracle run, his squad will be sitting out the tourney for the second consecutive season.
Smith has won 51.2% of his games over four seasons at Utah, and will likely miss the NCAAs again this year, after missing his first three years.
Sprinkle is under .500 in his first year at Washington and his team will very likely not get an NCAA invite.
The two successful ones:
Wade — 67.3% winning percentage at LSU, with three NCAA appearances in five seasons. NCAA troubles doomed him.
Eustachy — 63.1% in five seasons at Iowa State, with two NCAA appearances. He was bought out due to morality issues — he had a thing for college coed booty.