šŸ”„ The @HooandTrue General Portal 2025 Thread

https://x.com/matthewcoca/status/1904320182647939259?s=46

6 Likes

We’ll see what the numbers are at the end…should be lower without the 5th year players. I think it’s just the shorter window combined with more agent involvement…it’s getting more organized basically. Better to get in early.

9 Likes

Yeah, with the huge $ being thrown around, schools and donors are gonna want some sort - or many sorts - of guarantees or reimbursements - or who knows what they’ll come up with? It’s wild and the rules, such as they are, seem very - how should I put it - very flexible.

2 Likes

Plus, if collectives have to Puke 🤮 their cash in the next 2 months, it’s time to make hay

Edit: I did not use a Puke 🤮 emoji

Edit2: there is a Puke 🤮 emoji glitch

6 Likes

Transfer fees only exist because multi year contracts exist (it’s the buying out of the rest of the contract). No transfer fees when a soccer player runs down his contract to the end and doesn’t renew.

This is where UVA has already failed. Tennessee lost both big men to the portal last year. (Aidoo & Awaka) Instead of rolling with their development guys like Phillips and Estrella, they actually went out and bought two experienced dudes in Okpara and Milicic. Good thing too, because Estrella had a foot issue and was shut down in late November.

When you have a glaring need, you have to fill it. UVA did a half ass job when all the bigs bounced after 23.

The biggest difference between Tennessee & UVA this past year athleticism & physicality. The Vols have some grown ass men & a true PG, while UVA did not.

3 Likes

29 Likes

I will neither confirm nor deny I have anything to do with this. @DFresh11 is my witness.

4 Likes

I can see Fresh standing next to you saying ā€œYou should add a poll while you’re at itā€.

3 Likes

I mean, it does though. Like 90% of NBA players play out their contracts, or if they are traded, it’s the team’s decision. The only guys with enough market power to force trades and quiet quit until they get what they want are the stars and maybe a few in the tier just below that. It gets a lot of attention and can look obnoxious, but most of the league is fairly stable. And because of contracts, even when a super star forces a move, their team can still get something in return.

There’s no comparison between that and the total shitshow that is CBB right now. Every player being a free agent every year is insanity. There is a reason no professional sports league on earth is run like this.

Anyway, you probably weren’t trying to say contracts are useless - I’m just riffing off it. But the current state of things just drives me crazy. Nobody would ever design this system purposefully. We’ve just fallen into it due to so much incompetence and it’s exhausting. I miss just having a team and recruiting high school kids with an occasional transfer who you knew wanted to finish out their career with you. The whole fun part of college sports was you could get to know the guys and watch them develop. Now you’ve got guys cycling between three schools in three years and we’re all talking about single-year mercenaries. If my pro team signs a dude I get to follow him for more than a year for goodness sake. The pros aren’t supposed to provide a better chance to bond with players than college!

Rant over…. Back to the portal.

12 Likes

Counterpoint: I enjoy the annual roster reinvention, I enjoy never feeling ā€œstuckā€ with a middling roster, and I enjoy VIP status on a site that specializes in tracking, charting, and explaining everything!

12 Likes

Yeah it’s so hard stay invested. I barely pay attention to high school recruits anymore knowing it’s a low chance if they will fully develop at their original school. I’m all for players getting paid. I just want some structure.

5 Likes

The portal** makes some die-hards more die-hard (guilty), but it pushes away the casuals. Guess which is more important for the overall health of the sport…

** by which I mean the no-sit out rules, NIL, and no regime to incent guys to stick around over the long term.

5 Likes

Viewership is up this year

1 Like

Tourney viewers are, right? I saw that, too…

We shall see.

1 Like

Yep, longer engagement period for diehards, and you have increased legalized betting which helps you farm engagement from that crowd during the season. There is no going back to what it was. Best case for those who want stability is multi-year contracts. Still can’t force a player to play but could force buyouts.

2 Likes

The thing I most want to see is some sort of compensation for the team losing the player. Doesn’t necessarily have to be money.

4 Likes

Would also like to see someone collect data on the % of guys who enter the portal but return to their original school. Think that number will increase too.

1 Like

Yeah up like 8-9%. I suspect it could be because of Cinderella’s absence. Less exciting with no mid major runs, but big schools have lots of fans.

6 Likes

Waiting on the Luke Bam transfer highlights to drop and was getting annoyed they havent already, until I realized SEVEN HUNDRED people entered yesterday. My guy is swamped!

3 Likes